Burden of aortic stenosis likely to challenge UK treatment capacity, researchers warn


Researchers have warned that the number of people suffering from aortic valve stenosis in the UK could place an increasing burden on the country’s capacity to treat the disease in coming years.

This comes amid research published in the open access journal Open Heart, suggesting that an estimated 300,000 people in the UK have aortic valve stenosis, in which a significant proportion are “silent” cases, with symptoms appearing only when the condition is already advanced.

The researchers, including lead author Geoffrey Strange (University of Notre Dame, Freemantle, Australia), as well as co-authors Nick Curzen (University Hospital Southampton NHS Foundation Trust, Southampton, UK) and Simon Kendall (president of the Society of Cardiothoracic Surgeons of Great Britain & Ireland), set out to provide informed estimates of the overall prevalence of severe aortic stenosis across the UK and how many people might benefit from either surgical aortic valve replacement (SAVR) or transcatheter aortic valve implantation (TAVI).

To gauge the numbers potentially at risk of aortic stenosis, the researchers obtained national age and sex-specific population data for the year 2019, when nearly a third (30%; 20.1 million) of the UK’s 66 million population were aged 55 and older.

To come up with valid and accurate age specific prevalence estimates, they drew on data from one of the largest ever studies of the condition to date (NEDA study). This had come up with a prevalence of severe disease of 3.5% among the over 75s.

Using this as a reference point, they estimated the prevalence of severe aortic stenosis as 1.2% among 70–74 year olds; 0.7% among 65–69 year olds; 0.5% among 60–64 year olds; and 0.4% among 55–59 year olds in 2019.

They then estimated the proportions of those with and without symptoms, and of those with symptoms, how many could be managed with drugs and how many would need surgery, based on historical treatment patterns.

And they calculated how many people would die, if left untreated, based on the estimated total numbers of people diagnosed with the condition in 2019, and actual five-year death rates observed among the untreated in the NEDA study.

Based on all these figures, the researchers estimate that the overall prevalence of severe aortic stenosis among the over 55s in the UK in 2019 to be almost 1.5%, equal to around 300,000 people living with this potentially deadly condition at any one time.

Of the total numbers with aortic stenosis, just under 200,000 (68%) had severe disease in 2019, prompting the need for around 116,000 SAVR and 51,000 TAVI procedures, the researchers estimate.

But the 92,389 people with ‘silent’ disease, representing nearly a third of all cases (32%), will probably not be diagnosed unless they are being proactively screened for aortic stenosis or undergoing tests for another heart problem, they suggest.

Without timely proactive treatment, the researchers calculate that up to 172,859 of those with severe aortic stenosis (59%, overall) in 2019 will die over the next five years to 2024, equal to 35,000 people every year.

Nearly 10,000 of these deaths (almost 6% of all cases) will be among 55–64 year olds, with an additional 29,548 deaths (17%) among 65–74 year olds. Most deaths will occur in 75–84 year olds (86,383; 50%) and the over 85s (47,121; 27%), the researchers estimate.

Based on their estimates, the researchers question whether the UK health service will be able to cope with the prevalence of aortic disease over the next few years.

“Critically, such an indicative burden is far greater than the current capacity within the NHS to screen, detect, triage and treat such cases,” with the prevalence increasing further as the population ages, they warn.

“There seems little doubt, therefore, that there is a significant shortfall between interventions undertaken for severe [aortic stenosis] and our estimates of potential demand.”

The researchers acknowledge that they have no way of verifying their estimates, and advise that population data on the incidence and prevalence of aortic stenosis in the UK are inadequate, so their findings should be interpreted cautiously.

But their figures are in line with those in the few available previously published studies, they point out.

“In conclusion, this study suggests that severe [aortic stenosis] is a common condition affecting many individuals within the UK population aged 55 [and older]. Without appropriate detection and intervention, their survival prospects are likely to be poor.”


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here