Transcatheter left atrial appendage occlusion (LAAO) with a Watchman (Boston Scientific) device was associated with a low rate of stroke at one year, even among older patients with atrial fibrillation (AF) who faced a high risk for stroke or bleeding based on their previous health history, according to new data presented at the American College of Cardiology’s 70th Annual Scientific Session (ACC.21, 15–17 May, virtual).
Watchman was approved by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in 2015. The device is used to reduce the risk of stroke in patients with AF, as an alternative to the long-term use of anticoagulants. Anticoagulants may not be suitable for some patients due to drug interactions, side effects, logistical challenges or other reasons. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) specify that patients receiving the Watchman device should be at high risk for stroke and unable to take long-term oral anticoagulation.
The study, an analysis of ACC’s National Cardiovascular Data Registry (NCDR) LAAO Registry of patients who received a Watchman device, found that in practice, the rate of ischaemic stroke—the study’s primary endpoint—was generally on par with rates seen in clinical trials leading to the device’s approval. The findings offer reassurance that LAAO with the Watchman device is likely effective for the patient population currently receiving it, according to the researchers.
“Based on these data, it seems like we’re doing the right thing,” said Matthew J Price, director of the cardiac catheterisation laboratory at Scripps Clinic in La Jolla, USA, and the study’s lead author. “The rate of ischaemic stroke was low and supports the clinical effectiveness of transcatheter LAAO as it is currently applied in the USA.”
The researchers analysed data from more than 36,000 procedures recorded in the registry, that includes almost all LAAO procedures performed in the USA. The study includes data from patients who received a Watchman device in 2016, 2017 or 2018.
Patients in the registry were on average significantly older and at higher risk than those who were included in clinical trials for the WATCHMAN device, Price said. The average age of patients in the registry was 76 years; one-quarter of the patients had previously had a stroke, many were deemed to be at high risk for falls, and nearly 70% had previously experienced clinically relevant bleeding.
After a follow-up period of one year, an estimated 1.53% of patients in the registry suffered an ischemic stroke, 8.52% died and less than 0.7% experienced systemic embolism.
“I was actually a bit surprised by the relatively low event rates because the patients are substantially higher risk than those studied in clinical trials,” Price said. “However, all-cause mortality, as well as bleeding in the weeks following the procedure, were not infrequent—consistent with the co-morbidities of this patient population. This underscores the need to individualise one’s approach to stroke prevention so that patients reap the clinical benefit of stroke reduction.”
The rate of stroke was 77% lower than would be predicted by the patients’ CHA2DS2-VASc scores, a measure of stroke risk for patients with AF. The study focused only on outcomes from LAAO procedures using the Watchman device; future studies are planned to assess clinical efficacy at three and four years.
“By providing more data, I think this study continues to support LAAO in patients who are not suitable for long-term oral anticoagulation,” Price said. “The apparently low ischaemic stroke event rates also provide support for ongoing clinical trials for LAAO versus oral anticoagulants in patients who are suitable for long-term oral anticoagulation.”
As it is based on registry data, the study lacked a control group that did not receive the Watchman device for comparison. However, the event rates observed in the study are consistent with those in other registry studies and clinical trials. Price said future research could focus on assessing LAAO in a broader patient population and on outcomes from new devices or techniques for performing the procedure.