
Enhanced radiation protection devices (ERPDs) can significantly lower scatter radiation exposure to all members of the cardiac cath lab, as compared to standard shielding. That is according to the findings of a single-centre, prospective study published recently in the Journal of the American Heart Association (JAHA) by Santiago Garcia (The Christ Hospital, Cincinnati, USA) and colleagues.
In an effort to assess the potential for ERPDs to reduce occupational risks associated with working in the cardiac cath lab, Garcia et al prospectively allocated 135 cases to three different shielding conditions: standard shielding in group one, the EggNest Protect ERPD (Egg Medical) in group two, and the EggNest Complete ERPD (Egg Medical) in group three. The authors note that the EggNest Complete ERPD is an integrated system intended to provide protection against scatter radiation exposure above and below the table for everyone in the lab, including at the head of the table, where scatter is highest.
Real‐time dosimetry was used to measure radiation exposure at three positions—primary operator, assistant and circulating nurse—with the effective dose equivalent (EDE) being estimated and annualised to 300 cases per year. For each position, the dosimeters were positioned at five locations: the left hip and left shoulder under the lead apron, and the left hip, left shoulder and left temporal area over the lead apron.
For primary operators, the median dose per case was significantly lower with ERPD in all measured locations, the researchers report. The estimated annual collar dose in millirems—one thousandth of a Roentgen equivalent man (Rem) unit—was 86.7 with standard shielding, 59.3 with the Protect ERPD, and 25.5 with the Complete ERPD (p<0.001). Similarly, the median EDE‐1 per case was 0.17 millirems with standard shielding, 0.02 with Protect ERPD and 0.01 with Complete ERPD (p<0.001).
Similarly comprehensive findings were seen in both assistants and circulating nurses as well. For assistants, the median dose per case was significantly lower with ERPDs in all measured locations; the estimated annual collar dose was 62.1 millirems with standard shielding, 16.1 with Protect ERPD, and 9.8 with Complete ERPD (p<0.001). For circulating nurses, the median dose per case was also found to be significantly lower with ERPDs in all measured locations. The estimated annual doses with standard shielding, Protect ERPD and Complete ERPD were 26.6, 8.9 and 10.2 millirems, respectively (p=0.003).
Substudy on lead apron thicknesses
In addition, via a substudy including all 135 patients, Garcia et al aimed to evaluate total radiation exposure with different lead apron thicknesses—standard (0.5mm) and light (0.125mm)—in combination with both ERPDs.
For primary operators, the annualised EDE‐1 doses were 51.4 millirems under standard shielding and standard lead, 4.5 with Protect ERPD plus standard lead, and 22.5 with Protect ERPD plus light lead (p<0.001). For assistants, annualised EDE‐1 doses were 2.8 millirems under standard shielding and standard lead, 0.7 with Protect ERPD plus standard lead, and 5 with Protect ERPD plus light lead (p<0.001). Additionally, for circulating nurses, annualised EDE‐1 doses were 1.5 millirems under standard shielding and standard lead, 0.6 with Protect ERPD plus standard lead, and 1.9 with Protect ERPD plus light lead (p=0.108).
The researchers therefore posit that, using the EggNest Protect ERPD, each team member received lower annualised radiation doses when wearing ultra‐light 0.125mm lead aprons compared to standard lead aprons with standard shielding—though these dosages were not as low as those seen when using the Protect ERPD alongside standard lead aprons.
Furthermore, for primary operators, the annualised EDE‐1 doses were 3.1 millirems with the Complete ERPD under standard lead and 1.41 with the Complete ERPD under light lead—comparing favourably to the 51.4 millirems seen under standard shielding and standard lead (p<0.001). For assistants, the annualised EDE‐1 doses were 2.8 millirems with Complete ERPD under standard lead and 2.1 with Complete ERPD under light lead, while, for circulating nurses, annualised EDE‐1 doses were 0.55 millirems with Complete ERPD under standard lead, and 1 millirem with Complete ERPD under light lead. These figures compare favourably to the respective doses of 2.8 and 1.5 millirems seen with standard shielding and standard lead in assistants (p<0.001), and circulating nurses (p=0.184).
Garcia et al note that, as such, when using the EggNest Complete ERPD, both the standard and ultra‐light lead groups received less radiation than the standard shielding group with standard lead aprons, with no significant difference in the annualised doses between ultra‐light and standard lead aprons within the Complete ERPD group.
The researchers go on to state that clinicians in all three of the positions evaluated in this study—primary operators, scrub assistants/secondary operators, and circulating registered nurses—involved in 300 similar cases utilising ERPDs each year would receive <1% of the annual maximum of 5,000 millirems recommended by the International Commission on Radiological Protection (ICRP). They also relay that, regarding specific usage of the EggNest Complete ERPD without a lead apron, annualised total effective doses were ≤1% of this recommended annual maximum for all positions.
What do these findings mean?
“These data indicate that the addition of complete ERPD in the cardiac cath lab effectively reduces levels of scatter radiation to the extent that users could use either ultra‐light or no lead aprons under the principle of as low as reasonably achievable [ALARA],” Garcia et al write in their JAHA report. “Using light lead aprons or the potential of eliminating them entirely could lessen or eliminate orthopaedic injuries related to wearing conventional lead aprons. These findings have significant clinical implications for cardiac cath lab staff members involved in these procedures.”
The authors also highlight the fact that there is a “growing appreciation” of the hazardous effects of scattered radiation, as well as increased recognition of the trade-offs associated with conventional shielding strategies—including the orthopaedic injuries that have been linked to wearing heavy lead aprons.
In response to these concerns, they add, medical societies have issued recommendations on the “urgent and mandatory” adoption of enhanced radiation protection systems; for example, via an expert consensus statement published in the Journal of the Society for Cardiovascular Angiography & Interventions (JSCAI) by David Rizik (Banner University Medical Center, Scottsdale, USA) and colleagues earlier this year.
“The results of this study show similar protection to the primary and assistant positions compared with other ERPDs. However, an ideal radiation protection system for the cardiac cath lab is one that provides radiation protection to all members of the cardiac cath lab staff equally, offers seamless workflow integration, allows procedural versatility, and is supported by robust data,” Garcia et al conclude. “The EggNest systems can be used to protect all team members in the cardiac cath lab during coronary angiography and PCI [percutaneous coronary intervention] procedures, enabling them to operate without the need for traditional wearable lead aprons.”












