For heart failure patients, risk of in-hospital death has decreased; readmission rate has increased


An analysis of Medicare data from 1993 through 2006 for older patients hospitalised for heart failure indicates that along with a decrease in hospital length of stay, the rate of in-hospital and 30-day mortality has decreased, while the rate of hospital readmission and discharge to skilled nursing facilities has increased, according to a study in the 2 June 2010 issue of The Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA).

“During the last decade, the most prominent change in the acute care of patients with heart failure was a decreasing length of stay in hospi­tals,” the authors write. Whether this decrease may be associated with changes in outcomes is not known.

Hector Bueno, Hospital General Universitario Gregorio Maranon, Madrid, Spain, and colleagues conducted a study to determine if during a period of de­creasing length of hospital stay for heart failure, there were changes in short-term mortality, readmission and discharge to skilled nurs­ing facilities, using data from Medicare. The analysis included 6,955,461 Medi­care fee-for-service hospitalisations for heart failure between 1993 and 2006, with a 30-day follow-up.

Between 1993 and 2006, average length of stay decreased from 8.8 days to 6.3 days. The researchers found that in-hospital mortality decreased from 8.5% in 1993 to 4.3% in 2006, a 49% relative reduction; and the 30-day mortality rate decreased by 2.1%, from 12.8% to 10.7%. There was an increase in postdischarge mortality (from dis­charge to the 30th day after admis­sion), from 4.3% in 1993 to 6.4% in 2006.

In 1993, a total of 74% of heart failure patients were dis­charged to home or under home care service, compared to 66.9% of patients in 2006. Thirteen percent of patients were discharged to skilled nursing facilities in 1993; in 2006, that figure was 19.9%, a relative increase of 53%. Thirty-day readmission rates increased from 17.2% to 20.1%.

“The most striking finding is that the period was associated with an in­crease in 30-day readmission rate. Al­though we cannot demonstrate that the shortened hospital stay caused these changes, it is certainly plausible that the effort to discharge patients quickly has led to transfers to nonacute institu­tional settings and occasionally sent pa­tients out of the hospital before they were fully treated,” the authors wrote.

The researchers add that from the patient perspective, it is not clear that care in 2006 was markedly better than it was in 1993. “The outcome of pa­tients hospitalised for heart failure measured by short-term mortality has improved, which may be a result of better quality of care. However, because length of stay has substantially decreased, improve­ment is less than what might be suggested by in-hospital mortality. In contrast with that improvement, rates of readmission and discharge to skilled nursing facilities have increased, sug­gesting that patient outcomes, al­though better, have not improved in all areas.”

“The current model of care for older patients with heart failure in the United States may benefit from more attention to the care and outcomes in the early transi­tion period after hospital discharge and routine surveillance of how changes in practice affect patient outcomes.”